The table below lists individuals inducted as honorary members of the New York State Society of the Cincinnati.
| July 4th, 1784 | REV. STEPHEN GANO |
| " | JOHN LANSING |
| " | JAMES M'CLAUGHERY, Colonel |
| " | LEWIS MORRIS, Major-General, U.S. Army |
| " | THOMAS MOFFATT, Major |
| " | JONAS PLATT, Justice |
| " | PHILIP PELL, Jr., Judge Advocate, U.S. Army |
| " | JOHN MORIN SCOTT, Brigadier-General |
| " | PIERRE VAN CORTLANDT, Lieutenant-Governor of New York |
| " | DANIEL WILLIAMS, Captain |
| " | ROBERT YATES, Chief Justice |
| July 4th, 1786 | RICHARD MORRIS, Chief Justice |
| " | ROBERT R. LIVINGSTON, Chancellor |
| " | JAMES DUANE, Mayor of N.Y City |
| " | WILLIAM DUER, Secretary of the Treasury |
| " | JOHN SLOSS HOBART, Justice |
| July 4th, 1787 | HENRY LIVINGSTON |
| " | WILLIAM FLOYD, Colonel |
| April 19th, 1791 | STEPHEN VAN RENSSELAER (the Patroon) |
| " | JOHN HATHORNE, Colonel |
| July 4th, 1796 | JACOB MORTON |
| " | WILLIAM CONSTABLE |
| July 4th, 1800 | JOHN BARKER CHURCH |
| " | REV. WILLIAM LINN, D.D. |
| " | THOMAS TRUXTON, Captain, U.S. Navy |
| July 4th, 1803 | GOUVERNEUR MORRIS |
| July 4th, 1805 | REV. JOHN MITCHELL MASON, D.D. |
| July 4th, 1813 | STEPHEN DECATUR, Commodore, U.S. Navy |
| " | JACOB JONES, Captain, U.S. Navy |
| " | WILLIAM BAINBRIDGE, Commodore, U.S. Navy |
| " | OLIVER HAZZARD PERRY, Commodore, U.S. Navy |
| " | JAMES LAWRENCE, Captain, U.S. Navy |
| July 4th, 1815 | THOMAS MACDONOUGH, Commodore, U.S. Navy |
| " | ISAAC HULL, Captain, U.S. Navy |
| " | JOHNSTON BLAKELEY, Captain, U.S. Navy |
| " | LEWIS WARRINGTON, Captain, U.S. Navy |
| July 4th, 1818 | JACOB BROWN, Major-General, U.S. Army |
| February 24th, 1819 | ANDREW JACKSON, 7th President of the U.S. |
| July 4th, 1822 | RUFUS KING |
| July 4th, 1825 | BARON D'AURIER, Commander of the French Army |
| July 4th, 1827 | EDWARD LIVINGSTON, Chief Justice |
| July 4th, 1847 | STEPHEN W. KEARNEY, Major-General, U.S. Army |
| " | MATTHEW C. PERRY, Commodore, U.S. Navy |
| " | ZACHARY TAYLOR, 12th President of the U.S. |
| " | WILLIAM J. WORTH, Major-General, U.S. Army |
| July 4th, 1849 | WILLIAM G. BELKNAP, Major-General, U.S. Army |
| " | JOHN E. WOOL, Major-General, U.S. Army |
| July 4th, 1859 | JAMES BUCHANAN, 15th President of the U.S. |
| " | JOHN ALSOP KING, Governor of New York |
| July 4th, 1862 | ROBERT ANDERSON, Brigadier-General, U.S. Army |
| July 4th, 1866 | ULYSSES SIMPSON GRANT, 18th President of the U.S. |
| " | DAVID GLASGOW FARRAGUT, Rear Admiral, U.S. Navy |
| July 4th, 1879 | WILLIAM TECUMSEH SHERMAN, General, U.S. Army |
| July 4th, 1881 | WINFIELD SCOTT HANCOCK, Major-General, U.S. Army |
| prior to 1887 | GROVER CLEVELAND, 22nd and 24th President of the United States |
| prior to 1893 | OLIVER OTIS HOWARD, Major-General, U.S. Army |
| " | HONORABLE JOSHUA MELANCTHON ADDEMAN, Late Captain U.S. Volunteers |
| " | GEORGE CHAMPLIN MASON |
| " | HONORABLE WILLIAM PAINE SHEFFIELD |
| 1896 | EDWARD NICOLL DICKERSON |
| 1897 | NELSON APPLETON MILES, Lieutenant-General, U.S. Army |
| 1899 | GEORGE DEWEY, Admiral of the U.S. Navy |
| 1905 | ADNA ROMANZA CHAFFEE, Lieutenant-General, U.S. |
| 1902 | THEODORE ROOSEVELT, 26th President of the U.S. |
| 1916 | HUGH LEONARD SCOTT, Major-General, U.S. Army |
| 1918 | ELIHU ROOT, U.S. Secretary of State |
| 1919 | HIS MAJESTY ALBERT I, King of the Belgians |
| 1921 | ROBERT GEORGES NIVELLE, Commander-in-Chief,French Armies |
| 1925 | EMILE DAESCHNER, French Ambassador to the U.S. |
| 1934 | FRANKLIN DELANO ROOSEVELT, 32nd President of the United States |
| " | JOHN HUSTON FINLEY, American Academy of Art |
| 1935 | CHARLES COOK PAULDING |
| " | FREDERIC RENE COUDERT, U.S. Special Asst Attorney General |
| " | GEORGE CREIGHTON WEBB |
| 1937 | SIR RONALD CHARLES LINDSAY, Great Britain Ambassador to U.S. |
| " | NICHOLAS MURRAY BUTLER, President of Columbia University |
| " | COMTE CHARLES-HYPPOLITE-MARIE de FERRY de FONTNOUVELLE, Consul General of France |
| 1938 | CORDELL HULL, U.S. Secretary of State |
| 1939 | FRANK PETER HOFFMAN |
| 1950 | DOUGLAS MacARTHUR, General of the Army |
| " | OMAR NELSON BRADLEY, General of the Army |
| " | ROBERT E. WOOD, Brigadier-General, U.S. Army |
| 1955 | JOHN EDGAR HOOVER, Director, Federal Bureau of Investigation |
| 1959 | AMORY HOUGHTON, U.S. Ambassador to France |
| 1964 | ARLEIGH ALBERT BURKE, Admiral, U.S. Navy |
| 1970 | JOHN HOWLAND GIBBS PELL, Commander, U.S. Naval |
| 1971 | GILBERT DARLINGTON, Lieutenant Commander, Chaplain U.S. New York Naval Militia |
| May 13th, 1971 | BACHE BLEECKER, President Mount Gulian Society |
| 1973 | SPRUILLE BRADEN, U.S. Ambassador to Columbia, Cuba, Argentina |
| " | JOHN WHELCHEL FINGER, Governor General, NY Society of Colonial Wars |
| May 16th, 1975 | THOMAS FLEMING, Author and Historian |
| 1981 | WILLARD LEE BRABY |
| " | FRANÇOIS de LABOULAYE, French Ambassador to the United States |
| 1982 | SHELBY CULLOM DAVIS, U.S. Ambassador to Switzerland |
| November 4th, 1984 | WILLARD W. SCOTT, JR., Lieutenant- General; U.S. Army; Superintendent, U.S. Military Academy at West Point |
| 1988 | EMMANUEL de MARGERIE, French Ambassador to the United States |
| June 1st, 1989 | DAVID RICHARD PALMER, Lieutenant-General, U.S. Army; Superintendent, U.S. Military Academy at West Point |
| November 3rd, 1990 | FRANCIS LEONARD KELLOGG, Ambassador and Special Assistant to Secretaries of State Rogers and Kissinger |
| June 1st, 1991 | EDWARD NICHOLAS PENNINGTON GARDINER, Int'l Management Consultant |
| " | THEODORE S. WILKINSON, Lieutenant-Commander U.S. Naval Reserve; President, American Foreign Affairs, Mexico and Brazil |
| June 6th, 1992 | JACQUES ANDREANI, French Ambassador to the United States |
| 1994 | IMMO FRIEDRICH HELMUT STABREIT, Federal Republic of Germany, Ambassador to the United States |
| November 18th, 2000 | FRANÇOIS BUJON de l'ESTANG, French Ambassador to the United States |
| November 17th, 2007 | PIERRE VIMONT, French Ambassador to the United States |
| June 3rd, 2013 | FRANÇOIS DELATTRE, French Ambassador to the United States |
| June 3rd, 2023 | JAMES FORSYTH BLEECKER |
