The following list includes the names of officers that were either Original Members (O.M.) of the Society or officers eligible for membership in the Society, that were not represented after their death. Descendants of any of these officers may be eligible for membership in the New York Society of the Cincinnati.
| Surname | Given Name | Rank | Ending Continenal Regiment | O.M. |
| ARCHBALD | Edward | Captain-Lieutenant | Second Regiment of Continental Artillery | |
| BAGLEY | Josiah | Lieutenant | 3rd New York Regiment | O.M. |
| BALL | John | Lieutenant | 3rd New York Regiment | |
| BANKS | John | Deputy Commissary General | Commissariat Dept. New York Continental Line | |
| BARR | John | Ensign | 4th New York Regiment | |
| BARRETT | James | 2nd Lt. | 2nd New York Regiment | |
| BATEMAN | John | Adjutant | First Canadian Continental Regiment | |
| BETTS | James | 2nd Lt. | 4th New York Regiment | |
| BEVIER | Philip DuBois | Captain | 5th New York Regiment | |
| BICKER | Walter | Lieutenant 3rd Pennsylvania Regiment | O.M. | |
| BLACK | James | Captain | Malcolm's Additional Continental Regiment | |
| BLACKLEY | John | 2nd Lt. | First Canadian Continental Regiment | |
| BREWSTER | Caleb | Captain-Lieutenant | Second Regiment of Continental Artillery | O.M. |
| BRINDLEY | Francis | 2nd Lt. | First Canadian Continental Regiment | |
| BROWER | Garrett | Lieutenant | Second Regiment of Continental Artillery | |
| BRUYN | Jacobus Severyn | Lt. Col. | 3rd New York Regiment | |
| BURNET | Robert | 2nd Lt. | 2nd Regiment, Continental Artillery | O.M. |
| BURNSIDE | John | 2nd Lt. | Second Regiment of Continental Artillery | |
| CAMPBELL | Donald | Col., Deputy QM General | Continental Quartermaster's Department | |
| CAMPBELL | Duncan | 2nd Lt. | First Canadian Continental Regiment | O.M. |
| CAMPBELL | John | 2nd Lt. | Second Regiment of Continental Artillery | |
| CAPE | John | Lieutenant | 1st Regiment, New Jersey Continental Line | O.M. |
| CARPENTER | Nehemiah | Ensign | 2nd New York Regiment | O.M. |
| CEBRA | William | 2nd Lt. | Second Regiment of Continental Artillery | |
| CHANDONNET | Francis | Major | Continental Quartermaster's Department | |
| CHINN | Edward | Lieutenant/Paymaster | Second Canadian Continental Regiment | O.M. |
| COLBRATH | William | Lieutenant | 3rd New York Regiment | O.M. |
| CONINE | Philip | Captain-Lieutenant | 3rd New York Regiment | |
| CONKLIN | Silvanus | Lieutenant | 4th New York Regiment | |
| CONYNGHAM (Cunninghame) | Cornelius | Surgeon's Mate | Hospital Dept. Continental Army | |
| COOK | Ezekiel | Ensign | Second Canadian Continental Regiment | |
| COOKE | Samuel | Surgeon | 5th New York Regiment | |
| COVENTRY | John H. | Surgeon's Mate | Spencer's Additional Continental Regiment | |
| CRIMSHEIR | John Dutton | Paymaster | Second Regiment of Continental Artillery | O.M. |
| CRONIN | Patrick | Regimental Quartermaster | Malcolm's Additional Continental Regiment | |
| CUNNINGHAM | Henry | Lieutenant | Second Regiment of Continental Artillery | O.M. |
| CUTTING | John Brown | Apothecary-General | Middle Dept., Continental Army | |
| DAVIDSON | James | Commissary of Stores | Hospital Dept. Continental Army | O.M. |
| DAVIS | John | Major | 4th New York Regiment | |
| DEFENDORFF | Henry | Lieutenant | 3rd New York Regiment | |
| DEMLER | Henry | 2nd Lt. | Second Regiment of Continental Artillery | O.M. |
| DENNISTON | Daniel | Lieutenant | 3rd New York Regiment | O.M. |
| DOUGHTY | John | Captain | Second Regiment of Continental Artillery | O.M. |
| DOW | Alexander | Lieutenant | Malcolm's Additional Continental Regiment | |
| EGBERTS | Jacob Visscher | Surgeon's Mate | Hospital Dept. Continental Army | |
| ELLIOTT | John | Surgeon's Mate | 1st New York Regiment | O.M. |
| ELSWORTH | Peter | Captain-Lieutenant | 4th New York Regiment | |
| ENGLIS | Andrew | Captain-Lieutenant | 1st Regiment, Massachusetts Continental Infantry | O.M. |
| ENGLISH | Samuel | 2nd Lt. | 5th New York Regiment | |
| EVANS | Israel | Brigade Chaplain | 3rd Regiment, New Hampshire Continental Line | |
| FENNO | Ephraim | Captain-Lieutenant | Second Regiment of Continental Artillery | O.M. |
| FERRIOLE | Alexander | Lieutenant | Second Canadian Continental Regiment | |
| FLEMING | George | Captain | Second Regiment of Continental Artillery | O.M. |
| FONDEY | Douw I. | Ensign | 1st New York Regiment | O.M. |
| FONDEY | John | Ensign | 1st New York Regiment | O.M. |
| FOOT | Joseph | Lieutenant | 1st Regiment, Massachusetts Continental Line | O.M. |
| FOWLER | Theodosius | Captain | 4th New York Regiment | O.M. |
| FRANKS | John | Captain / Paymaster | 4th New York Regiment | |
| FRENCH | Abner | Captain | 2nd New York Regiment | |
| FRILICK | Joseph | Lieutenant | 2nd New York Regiment | O.M. |
| GARNETT | William | Surgeon's Mate | Second Canadian Continental Regiment | |
| GATES | Horatio | Major General | Continental Army | O.M. |
| GATES | John | Ensign | First Canadian Continental Regiment | |
| GILBERT | Benjamin | Lieutenant | 1st New York Regiment | O.M. |
| GILLILAND | James | Captain | Sappers and Miners, Continental Army | O.M. |
| GLENNEY | William | Lieutenant | 2nd New York Regiment | |
| GODWIN | Henry | Captain | 5th New York Regiment | |
| GRAHAM | Charles | Captain | 2nd New York Regiment | O.M. |
| GRAHAM | John | Major | 1st New York Regiment | O.M. |
| GREATON | John Wheewlright | Ensign | 3rd Massachusetts Regiment | O.M. |
| GUILMAT | Francis | Lieutenant | Second Canadian Continental Regiment | O.M. |
| HALE | Mordecai | Surgeon's Mate | Second Regiment of Continental Artillery | O.M. |
| HALLETT | Jonathan | Captain | 2nd New York Regiment | O.M. |
| HANMOR | Francis | Ensign | 5th New York Regiment | O.M. |
| HARDENBERGH | Abraham | Lieutenant | 1st New York Regiment | O.M. |
| HARDY | Joseph | Captain | Continental Marines | O.M. |
| HAY | Udny | Lt. Col. | Second Canadian Continental Regiment | |
| HENRY | Nathaniel | Lieutenant | 1st New York Regiment | O.M. |
| HICKS | Benjamin | Brigade Major | 1st New York Regiment | |
| HOOGHKERK | John | Captain | 1st New York Regiment | |
| HUGHES | Hugh | Deputy Quartermaster General | Continental Quartermaster's Department | |
| HUGHES | James Miles | Captain | Aide-de-Camp to General Horatio Gates | O.M. |
| HUTTON | Christopher | Lt./Adjutant | 2nd New York Regiment | O.M. |
| HUNT | Thomas | Lieutenant | 4th New York Regiment | O.M. |
| HUNTER | Elijah | Captain | Secret Service, Continental Army | |
| HUNTER | Robert | Lieutenant | Malcolm's Additional Continental Regiment | |
| HUTCHINSON | Ebenezer | Surgeon's Mate | 5th New York Regiment | |
| JACKSON | Patten | Lieutenant | 5th New York Regiment | |
| JACKSON | Thomas Tredwell | Lieutenant | ADC to MG Lord Stirling, Continental Army | O.M. |
| JOHNSTON | James | Lieutenant | 2nd New York Regiment | O.M. |
| JOLIBOIS | John | Lieutenant | First Canadian Continental Regiment | |
| KAGHNATSHON | Nicholas | Lieutenant | 1st New York Regiment | |
| KAHEKTOTOW | Cornelius | Lieutenant | 1st New York Regiment | |
| LANSING | Garrett | Lieutenant | 3rd New York Regiment | O.M. |
| LOGAN | Samuel | Major | 5th New York Regiment | O.M. |
| LAWRENCE | Oliver | Lieutenant | ADC to Gen. Parsons, Connecticut Line | |
| LENNINGTON | Thomas | Ensign | Nicholson's Additional Continental Regiment | |
| LEWIS | Samuel | Lieutenant | 1st New York Regiment | O.M. |
| LOTBINIERE | Francois-Louis Chartier de | Chaplain | First Canadian Continental Regiment | |
| LOUNSBURY | Edward | Captain | 2nd New York Regiment | |
| MACKINSON | James | Lieutenant | Second Regiment of Continental Artillery | |
| MAGEE | Peter | 2nd Lt. | 3rd New York Regiment | O.M. |
| MALCOLM | John | Lieutenant | Malcolm's Additional Continental Regiment | |
| MARSHALL | Elihu | Captain | 2nd New York Regiment | O.M. |
| MAYNARD | Antoine | Captain | First Canadian Continental Regiment | |
| MCARTHUR | Alexander | 2nd Lt. | 5th New York Regiment | |
| MCCLAUGHRY | John | Lieutenant | 2nd New York Regiment | |
| McCRACKEN | Joseph | Major | 4th New York Regiment | O.M. |
| McDOUGALL | Ranald Stephan | Major | Aide-de-Camp to General Alexander | O.M. |
| MCDOUGALL | John | Lieutenant | Frigate Randolph, Continental Navy | |
| MCLANE | Daniel | Lieutenant | 3rd Massachusetts Continental Artillery | O.M. |
| MCNAIR | James | Lieutenant | Second Regiment of Continental Artillery | |
| MCPHERSON | Murdock | Lieutenant | Hazen's Roll, Continental Invalid Regiment | O.M. |
| MENEMA | Daniel | Surgeon | 2nd New York Regiment | O.M. |
| MERSELIS | Henry | Deputy Wagon-Master | Continental Quartermaster's Department | |
| MILLER OR MULLER | Christopher | Lieutenant | 1st New York Regiment | |
| MILLER OR MULLER | Jeremiah | Ensign | 1st New York Regiment | |
| MILLS | Daniel | Captain | 1st New York Regiment | |
| MITCHELL | Uriah | Captain, Assistant Deputy QM Gen. | Quartermaster Dept. Continental Army | |
| MOODIE | Andrew | Captain | Second Regiment of Continental Artillery | O.M. |
| MOORE | Henry | Surgeon's Mate | Hospital Dept. Continental Army | |
| MOORE | James | Lieutenant | Second Regiment of Continental Artillery | |
| NEELY | Abraham | Captain | Spencer's Additional Continental Regiment | |
| NICHOLSON | George Chadine | Major | First Canadian Continental Regiment | |
| OKNOYATA | Cornelius | Lieutenant | Continental Corps of Indian Rangers | |
| OLIVER | Lawrence | Major | Second Canadian Continental Regiment | O.M. |
| OLIVER | Richard | Lieutenant | Spencer's Additional Continental Regiment | |
| OSTRANDER | Thomas | 2nd Lt. | 3rd New York Regiment | |
| OTAAWIGHTOW | John | Captain | Continental Corps of Indian Rangers | |
| PARKER | DANIEL Jr. | Captain | 3rd Massachusetts Continental Artillery | O.M. |
| PAULIENT | Antoine | Captain | 2nd Canadian Continental Regiment | O.M. |
| PAWLING | Albert | Major | Malcolm's Additional Continental Regiment | |
| PAWLING | Henry | Captain | 2nd New York Regiment | O.M. |
| PEMBERTON | Robert | Captain | Spencer's Additional Continental Regiment | O.M. |
| PENDLETON | Solomon | Lieutenant | 5th New York Regiment | |
| POST | Anthony | Captain | Continental Artillery Corps of Artificers | |
| POTAN | Matthew | Ensign | 3rd New York Regiment | |
| PRICE | William | Lieutenant | 3rd Massachusetts Continental Artillery | O.M. |
| PRIOR | Abner | Surgeon's Mate | 2nd New York Regiment | O.M. |
| PROVOST. | Robert | Ensign | 2nd New York Regiment | O.M. |
| RANDALL | Thomas | Captain | 3rd Massachusetts Continental Artillery | O.M. |
| REED | Jacob Jr. | Captain | Second Regiment of Continental Artillery | O.M. |
| REED | John | 2nd Lt. | Second Regiment of Continental Artillery | O.M. |
| REID or REED | Thomas | Surgeon | First Canadian Continental Regiment | |
| ROBICHEAU | James | Captain | First Canadian Continental Regiment | |
| ROSEKRANS | James | Major | 3rd New York Regiment | |
| ROUSSI | Pierre Regnier de | Col. | 2nd New York Regiment | O.M. |
| RUTAN | Peter | Lieutenant | First Canadian Continental Regiment | |
| RYCKMAN | Wilhelmus | Lieutenant | 1st New York Regiment | O.M. |
| SAGOHARASE | John | Lieutenant | Continental Corps of Indian Rangers | |
| SALISBURY | Barent Staats | Captain-Lieutenant | 1st New York Regiment | |
| SAMPSON | Ezekiel | Lieutenant | Continental Artillery Corps of Artificers | |
| SCUDDER | William | Lieutenant | 1st New York Regiment | O.M. |
| SHAW | John | 2nd Lt. | 2nd Regiment, Continental Artillery | O.M. |
| SHERWOOD | Adiel | Lieutenant | 1st New York Regiment | |
| SHERWOOD | Isaac | 2nd Lt. | 1st New York Regiment | |
| SMITH | George | Judge Advocate | Northern Dept., Continental Army | |
| SMITH | Isaac | Surgeon | Hospital Dept. Continental Army | |
| SMITH | Isaac | 2nd Lt. | Second Regiment of Continental Artillery | O.M. |
| SNOW | Ephraim | Lieutenant | 1st New York Regiment | O.M. |
| STAKE | John | Cornet | Continental Corps of Light Dragoons | O.M. |
| STARR | Jehoshaphat | Ensign | 2nd Regiment, Connecticut Continental Line | O.M. |
| STEDDIFORD | Gerard | Captain | 4th Pennsylvania Regiment | O.M. |
| STEWART | James | Captain | 5th New York Regiment | O.M. |
| STOCKWELL | Levi | Lieutenant | 3rd New York Regiment | |
| STORER | Ebenezer | Lieutenant/Paymaster | 12th Massachusetts Regiment (MA/NY) | O.M. |
| STOTESBURY | John | Captain | 6th Pennsylvania Regiment | O.M. |
| SWAN | Caleb | Ensign | 9th Regiment, Massachusetts Continental Line | O.M. |
| SWITS | Walter | Lieutenant | Warner's Additional Continental Regiment | |
| SYTEZ | George | Captain | 1st New York Regiment | O.M. |
| TAPPEN | Peter | Surgeon | Hospital Dept., Continental Army | |
| TAULMAN | Peter | Captain-Lieutenant | Continental Corps, Sappers & Miners | O.M. |
| TEARSE | Peter Bailey | Lieutenant/Adjutant | 1st New York Regiment | |
| TEN BROECK | Adam | Ensign | 1st New York Regiment | O.M. |
| TEN BROECK | John Cornelius | Captain | 1st New York Regiment | O.M. |
| TEN EYCK | John De Peyster | Capt-Lieutenant | 1st Canadian Continental Regiment | O.M. |
| TEWAHANGARAGHAN | Hanyere | Captain | Continental Corps of Indian Rangers | |
| TEWAHANGARAHKEN | Honyost | Lieutenant | Continental Corps of Indian Rangers | |
| THOMPSON | Andrew | Lieutenant | Spencer's Additional Continental Regiment | |
| THOMPSON | Thomas | Captain-Lieutenant | Second Regiment of Continental Artillery | |
| THOMPSON | Thomas | Lieutenant/Quartermaster | Second Canadian Continental Regiment | O.M. |
| TIEBOUT | Henry | Captain | 1st New York Regiment | O.M. |
| TITUS | Jonathan | Captain | 4th New York Regiment | |
| TREAT | Samuel | Captain-Lieutenant | 3rd Massachusetts Continental Artillery | |
| TUNISON | Gerret | Surgeon | Second Regiment of Continental Artillery | |
| TUTHILL | Azariah | Lieutenant | 4th New York Regiment | |
| VAN HORNE | David | Lieutenant | 1st New York Regiment | O.M. |
| VAN INGEN | Dirk | Surgeon | Hospital Dept., Continental Army | |
| VAN WART | Isaac | Lieutenant | 2nd New York Regiment | |
| VAN WOERT | Henry | Lieutenant | 1st New York Regiment | O.M. |
| VANDERHEYDEN | Nanning | Lieutenant | 3rd New York Regiment | |
| VERGEREAU | Peter | 2nd Lt. | 1st New York Regiment | |
| VISSCHER | John | Lt. Col. | New York Continental Line | |
| WAKARANTHROW | James | Captain | Continental Corps of Indian Rangers | |
| WALDRON | John | Captain-Lieutenant | Second Regiment of Continental Artillery | O.M. |
| WALKER | Benjamin | Lt. Col. | ADC to Gen. George Washington, Continental Army | O.M. |
| WARNER | Thomas | Lieutenant | 3rd New York Regiment | |
| WELP | Anthony | Lieutenant/Adjutant | First Canadian Continental Regiment | |
| WETZELL | Michael | 2nd Lt. | Second Regiment of Continental Artillery | O.M. |
| WHITE | Andrew | 2nd Lt. | 2nd New York Regiment | O.M. |
| WILLIAMS | Bedford | Surgeon | Hospital Dept. Continental Army | |
| WILLIAMS | Henry Abraham | Lieutenant | Second Regiment of Continental Artillery | |
| WILLIAMS | Thomas | Regimental Quartermaster | 3rd New York Regiment | |
| WILSON | Alexander | Lieutenant | Second Canadian Continental Regiment | |
| WATERMAN | Jedediah | Ensign | 8th Massachusetts Regiment | O.M. |
| WATSON | James | Commissary of Purchases | Commasariat Dept, Continental Army (CT/NY) | O.M. |
| WOOD | Daniel | Captain/Surgeon | Malcolm's Additional Continental Regiment | |
| WOOD | Robert | Lieutenant | 2nd New York Regiment | |
| WOODRUFF | Hunloke | Surgeon | 3rd New York Regiment | |
| WOODRUFF | Samuel | Surgeon's Mate | Hospital Dept. Continental Army | |
| WOODWARD | Peter | Lieutenant | Second Regiment of Continental Artillery | O.M. |
| WOOL | Isaiah | Captain | Second Regiment of Continental Artillery | |
| WRIGHT | Jacob | Captain | 2nd New York Regiment | O.M. |
| WRIGHT | John Groesbeck | Surgeon's Mate | Hospital Dept. Continental Army | |
| WRIGHT | Jotham | Lieutenant | Continental Artillery Corps of Artificers | |
| WRIGHT | Robert | Captain | First Canadian Continental Regiment | |
| YEOMANS | Moses | 2nd Lt. | 3rd New York Regiment |
